Nonoperative treatment is based on immobilization of the IP joint in extension for 6 weeks, leaving the MCP joint free.
Double avulsion injuries treated nonoperatively require close radiographic follow up to evaluate fracture stability.
The IP joint should be splinted.
Using a dorsal splint has the advantage of leaving the patient with the ability to pinch.
However, proponents of palmar splinting argue that the palmar aspect is better cushioned than the dorsal and, thereby, can tolerate the splint better.
The advantage of a custom thermoplastic splint is that it is adapted better to the shape of the thumb and is easier to change.
Apply a dorsal thumb spica splint with the wrist and IP joint in neutral position and MCP joint in 20° flexion for 5–6 weeks.
The aftercare can be divided into four phases of healing:
Full details on each healing phase can be found in the chapter Postoperative treatment of thumb injuries.
The splint allows for movement at the MCP joint and helps with pain and edema control. The arm should be actively elevated to help reduce the swelling.
Hand therapy is recommended to prevent soft-tissue atrophy and joint contracture, which leads to a poor outcome, and subsequent treatment is difficult.
Functional exercises of the nonimmobilized joints should be started immediately to keep the uninjured joints mobile.
X-ray controls have to be performed immediately after the splint has been applied. After 1 week, the fracture stability should be checked radiographically.
Strict immobilization for 6 weeks is needed for stable healing and good outcome. An x-ray without the splint is then taken. At this point, the fracture is usually still visible on x-ray. The decision about further treatment is based on clinical examination (no pain to pressure on the fracture zone).
After this period, start weaning the splint during daytime.